Hello, I added in point 3) Capnproto, 3)RD/RT and 4)EVPN some precisions. On Mon, Dec 5, 2016 at 2:34 PM, Lou Berger <lberger@labn.net> wrote:
Yes,
5) handling changes in coding conventions - yes this is prompted by the guarded debug logging discussion.
Lou
On 12/5/2016 8:21 AM, Donald Sharp wrote:
1) Status 2) Branching Discussion 3) CAP-N-PROTO email
https://lists.quagga.net/pipermail/quagga-dev/2016-December/016510.html
3) RD/RT
o RD/RT config impementation review https://lists.quagga.net/pipermail/quagga-dev/2016-December/016504.html o I had a question about network command under bgp vrf subnode. It does the same as if I was using network under address-family subnode. I mean it creates an entry in global RIB. Right ? If yes, then I suppose that the BGP daemon can be configured with 2 addresses families. Let's suppose EVPN and VPNv4. So, does that mean that the command is applied to both families ?
4) EVPN
By looking deeper at EVPN implementation from Cumulus. I have some remarks: - about the way to configure the VNI. I think it could be possible to append vni configuiration into bgp vrf subnode. Like that, it should be possible to have automatic values configured ( by vni value), or setting the wished values. This would permit from benefiting from current vrf implementation ( multiple import export communities instead of one). Whatever, the automatic mecanism to get import RT and RD is good to keep. - about prefix impact, I see that the vni ID is kept in prefix.h. If we want to have an EVPN implementation that works for MPLs and VXLan, it should be better to use eth_tag instead ( defined by rfc7432). - about the creation of entries, all MAC-only entries are derived from information retrieved by Zebra. Unless unnoticed, is there a way to configure an entry by using vty command. Based on this assumption, what about following proposal of adding a RT2 set command EVPN RT2 support + RouterMAC BGP extended community network A.B.C.D rd ASN:nn_or_IP-address:nn ethtag WORD mac WORD esi WORD l2label WORD l3label WORD routermac WORD Best Regards, Philippe