Hi all, I'm using quagga-0.99, I set a route-map by vtysh like this: vtysh# prefix-list ARP2HOST_PL3 ...
vtysh# route-map ARP2HOST_RM2 deny sequence 6 vtysh# match interface lo vtysh# route-map ARP2HOST_RM2, permit, sequence 10 vtysh# match ip address prefix-list ARP2HOST_PL3
But I found there are two SAME route-map exist in zebra and bgpd, like this: vtysh# show route-map
ZEBRA: route-map ARP2HOST_RM2, deny, sequence 6 Match clauses: interface eth0 Set clauses: Call clause: Action: Exit routemap route-map ARP2HOST_RM2, permit, sequence 10 Match clauses: ip address prefix-list ARP2HOST_PL3 Set clauses: Call clause: Action: Exit routemap BGP: route-map ARP2HOST_RM2, deny, sequence 6 Match clauses: Set clauses: Call clause: Action: Exit routemap route-map ARP2HOST_RM2, permit, sequence 10 Match clauses: ip address prefix-list ARP2HOST_PL3 Set clauses: metric 13 community 0:100 Call clause: Action: Exit routemap
And when I use command
vtysh# redistribute static route-map ARP2HOST_RM2
the redistribute will NOT process any static route SOMETIME, not always !!! Then I compare by add route-map through zebra.conf and bgpd.conf, like this:
zebra.conf: route-map ARP2HOST_RM2 deny sequence 6 match interface lo
bgpd.conf: prefix-list ARP2HOST_PL3 ... route-map ARP2HOST_RM2, permit, sequence 10 match ip address prefix-list ARP2HOST_PL3
And show route-map result beome:
vtysh# show route-map ZEBRA: route-map ARP2HOST_RM2, deny, sequence 6 Match clauses: interface eth0 Set clauses: Call clause: Action: Exit routemap BGP: route-map ARP2HOST_RM2, permit, sequence 10 Match clauses: ip address prefix-list ARP2HOST_PL3 Set clauses: metric 13 community 0:100 Call clause: Action: Exit routemap
Then the redistribute will work. focus on code, I guess ALL of zebra(zebra_routemap.c) and bgpd(bgp_routemap.c) will process route-map from vtysh command, which cause this bug? If it is, how to set route-map correctly by vtysh? Thanks !!! ---- Simon Jones
by the way: Why this route-map rule can't add into bgpd.conf, which will report ERROR and bgpd will NOT start? This could only add in zebra.conf
vtysh# route-map ARP2HOST_RM2 deny sequence 6 vtysh# match interface lo
But when I test this rule, I found this rule could NOT WORK at all !!! For ex: I add static route
vtysh# ip route 1.1.1.1/32 2.2.2.2 vtysh# redistribute static
As for this rule in zebra.conf, this redistribute route could NOT redistribute into bgp.rib
vtysh# route-map ARP2HOST_RM2 deny sequence 6 vtysh# match interface lo
But actually this route IS ADDED into bgp.rib ---- Simon Jones Simon Jones <batmanustc@gmail.com> 于2020年4月21日周二 上午9:08写道：
Hi all,
I'm using quagga-0.99, I set a route-map by vtysh like this:
vtysh# prefix-list ARP2HOST_PL3 ...
vtysh# route-map ARP2HOST_RM2 deny sequence 6 vtysh# match interface lo vtysh# route-map ARP2HOST_RM2, permit, sequence 10 vtysh# match ip address prefix-list ARP2HOST_PL3
But I found there are two SAME route-map exist in zebra and bgpd, like this:
vtysh# show route-map
ZEBRA: route-map ARP2HOST_RM2, deny, sequence 6 Match clauses: interface eth0 Set clauses: Call clause: Action: Exit routemap route-map ARP2HOST_RM2, permit, sequence 10 Match clauses: ip address prefix-list ARP2HOST_PL3 Set clauses: Call clause: Action: Exit routemap BGP: route-map ARP2HOST_RM2, deny, sequence 6 Match clauses: Set clauses: Call clause: Action: Exit routemap route-map ARP2HOST_RM2, permit, sequence 10 Match clauses: ip address prefix-list ARP2HOST_PL3 Set clauses: metric 13 community 0:100 Call clause: Action: Exit routemap
And when I use command
vtysh# redistribute static route-map ARP2HOST_RM2
the redistribute will NOT process any static route SOMETIME, not always !!!
Then I compare by add route-map through zebra.conf and bgpd.conf, like this:
zebra.conf: route-map ARP2HOST_RM2 deny sequence 6 match interface lo
bgpd.conf: prefix-list ARP2HOST_PL3 ... route-map ARP2HOST_RM2, permit, sequence 10 match ip address prefix-list ARP2HOST_PL3
And show route-map result beome:
vtysh# show route-map ZEBRA: route-map ARP2HOST_RM2, deny, sequence 6 Match clauses: interface eth0 Set clauses: Call clause: Action: Exit routemap BGP: route-map ARP2HOST_RM2, permit, sequence 10 Match clauses: ip address prefix-list ARP2HOST_PL3 Set clauses: metric 13 community 0:100 Call clause: Action: Exit routemap
Then the redistribute will work.
focus on code, I guess ALL of zebra(zebra_routemap.c) and bgpd(bgp_routemap.c) will process route-map from vtysh command, which cause this bug?
If it is, how to set route-map correctly by vtysh?
Thanks !!!
---- Simon Jones
Simon - I would highly recommend upgrading from Quagga 0.99.ANYTHING to the latest FRR release. There has been substantial improvements and bug fixes in the intervening 5 years. Having said that. Both zebra and bgp are going to have different ideas of what the routemap is ( hence the show route-map command showing everyone's view of it. ). donald On Mon, Apr 20, 2020 at 9:38 PM Simon Jones <batmanustc@gmail.com> wrote:
Hi all,
I'm using quagga-0.99, I set a route-map by vtysh like this:
vtysh# prefix-list ARP2HOST_PL3 ... vtysh# route-map ARP2HOST_RM2 deny sequence 6 vtysh# match interface lo vtysh# route-map ARP2HOST_RM2, permit, sequence 10 vtysh# match ip address prefix-list ARP2HOST_PL3
But I found there are two SAME route-map exist in zebra and bgpd, like this:
vtysh# show route-map ZEBRA: route-map ARP2HOST_RM2, deny, sequence 6 Match clauses: interface eth0 Set clauses: Call clause: Action: Exit routemap route-map ARP2HOST_RM2, permit, sequence 10 Match clauses: ip address prefix-list ARP2HOST_PL3 Set clauses: Call clause: Action: Exit routemap BGP: route-map ARP2HOST_RM2, deny, sequence 6 Match clauses: Set clauses: Call clause: Action: Exit routemap route-map ARP2HOST_RM2, permit, sequence 10 Match clauses: ip address prefix-list ARP2HOST_PL3 Set clauses: metric 13 community 0:100 Call clause: Action: Exit routemap
And when I use command
vtysh# redistribute static route-map ARP2HOST_RM2
the redistribute will NOT process any static route SOMETIME, not always !!!
Then I compare by add route-map through zebra.conf and bgpd.conf, like this:
zebra.conf: route-map ARP2HOST_RM2 deny sequence 6 match interface lo
bgpd.conf: prefix-list ARP2HOST_PL3 ... route-map ARP2HOST_RM2, permit, sequence 10 match ip address prefix-list ARP2HOST_PL3
And show route-map result beome:
vtysh# show route-map ZEBRA: route-map ARP2HOST_RM2, deny, sequence 6 Match clauses: interface eth0 Set clauses: Call clause: Action: Exit routemap BGP: route-map ARP2HOST_RM2, permit, sequence 10 Match clauses: ip address prefix-list ARP2HOST_PL3 Set clauses: metric 13 community 0:100 Call clause: Action: Exit routemap
Then the redistribute will work.
focus on code, I guess ALL of zebra(zebra_routemap.c) and bgpd(bgp_routemap.c) will process route-map from vtysh command, which cause this bug?
If it is, how to set route-map correctly by vtysh?
Thanks !!!
---- Simon Jones _______________________________________________ frog mailing list frog@lists.frrouting.org https://lists.frrouting.org/listinfo/frog
I would highly recommend upgrading from Quagga 0.99.ANYTHING to the latest FRR release. There has been substantial improvements and bug fixes
Including multiple security fixes. To expound on Donald's routemap comment a bit - you're probably seeing this because you're using separate config files for each daemon. If you use quagga.conf (or frr.conf) and apply that with vtysh, vtysh will handle distributing daemon specific config to just the daemons that understand it. On Tue, Apr 21, 2020, 9:42 AM Donald Sharp <sharpd@cumulusnetworks.com> wrote:
Simon -
I would highly recommend upgrading from Quagga 0.99.ANYTHING to the latest FRR release. There has been substantial improvements and bug fixes in the intervening 5 years.
Having said that. Both zebra and bgp are going to have different ideas of what the routemap is ( hence the show route-map command showing everyone's view of it. ).
donald
On Mon, Apr 20, 2020 at 9:38 PM Simon Jones <batmanustc@gmail.com> wrote:
Hi all,
I'm using quagga-0.99, I set a route-map by vtysh like this:
vtysh# prefix-list ARP2HOST_PL3 ... vtysh# route-map ARP2HOST_RM2 deny sequence 6 vtysh# match interface lo vtysh# route-map ARP2HOST_RM2, permit, sequence 10 vtysh# match ip address prefix-list ARP2HOST_PL3
But I found there are two SAME route-map exist in zebra and bgpd, like
this:
vtysh# show route-map ZEBRA: route-map ARP2HOST_RM2, deny, sequence 6 Match clauses: interface eth0 Set clauses: Call clause: Action: Exit routemap route-map ARP2HOST_RM2, permit, sequence 10 Match clauses: ip address prefix-list ARP2HOST_PL3 Set clauses: Call clause: Action: Exit routemap BGP: route-map ARP2HOST_RM2, deny, sequence 6 Match clauses: Set clauses: Call clause: Action: Exit routemap route-map ARP2HOST_RM2, permit, sequence 10 Match clauses: ip address prefix-list ARP2HOST_PL3 Set clauses: metric 13 community 0:100 Call clause: Action: Exit routemap
And when I use command
vtysh# redistribute static route-map ARP2HOST_RM2
the redistribute will NOT process any static route SOMETIME, not always
!!!
Then I compare by add route-map through zebra.conf and bgpd.conf, like
this:
zebra.conf: route-map ARP2HOST_RM2 deny sequence 6 match interface lo
bgpd.conf: prefix-list ARP2HOST_PL3 ... route-map ARP2HOST_RM2, permit, sequence 10 match ip address prefix-list ARP2HOST_PL3
And show route-map result beome:
vtysh# show route-map ZEBRA: route-map ARP2HOST_RM2, deny, sequence 6 Match clauses: interface eth0 Set clauses: Call clause: Action: Exit routemap BGP: route-map ARP2HOST_RM2, permit, sequence 10 Match clauses: ip address prefix-list ARP2HOST_PL3 Set clauses: metric 13 community 0:100 Call clause: Action: Exit routemap
Then the redistribute will work.
focus on code, I guess ALL of zebra(zebra_routemap.c) and bgpd(bgp_routemap.c) will process route-map from vtysh command, which cause this bug?
If it is, how to set route-map correctly by vtysh?
Thanks !!!
---- Simon Jones _______________________________________________ frog mailing list frog@lists.frrouting.org https://lists.frrouting.org/listinfo/frog
_______________________________________________ frog mailing list frog@lists.frrouting.org https://lists.frrouting.org/listinfo/frog
participants (3)
-
Donald Sharp -
Quentin Young -
Simon Jones