[FROG] [dev] Any CentOS/RedHat 6 FRR users out there?

Renato Westphal renato at opensourcerouting.org
Tue Oct 2 09:51:14 EDT 2018


For everyone's information, we've managed to build libyang packages
for CentOS 6. So we shouldn't need to drop support for this platform
anymore, at least not at this point in time. Thanks everyone for your
input!
On Mon, Oct 1, 2018 at 1:06 PM Lou Berger <lberger at labn.net> wrote:
>
> sounds reasonable...
>
>
> On 10/1/2018 9:25 AM, Donald Sharp wrote:
> > I don't but I also don't want to say never and have new information
> > show up that I was not expecting.
> >
> > donald
> > On Mon, Oct 1, 2018 at 8:52 AM Lou Berger <lberger at labn.net> wrote:
> >> Donald,
> >>
> >> We had the same discussion a few months ago? Why do we think the answer is
> >> going to be any different?
> >>
> >> lou
> >>
> >>
> >> ----------
> >> On October 1, 2018 8:23:39 AM Donald Sharp <sharpd at cumulusnetworks.com> wrote:
> >>
> >>> Jim -
> >>>
> >>> This is about PR: https://github.com/FRRouting/frr/pull/2705
> >>>
> >>> We would like to introduce a new library dependency.  My understanding
> >>> is that this library is not easily available for 6.X releases of RHEL
> >>> at this point in time.  As such we are trying to understand what we
> >>> would like to do.  We do not think it is unreasonable for people to be
> >>> still using old releases.  Typically in the past, as suggested earlier
> >>> in the email thread, we say release Y(and future versions) of FRR is
> >>> not supported on older versions of release X.  I am not necessarily
> >>> saying what we will do here though as that this is still early in the
> >>> figure this out process.
> >>>
> >>> donald
> >>> On Mon, Oct 1, 2018 at 7:57 AM Jim Carroll <jim at carroll.com> wrote:
> >>>> If you're looking for a head count, we are using RHEL 6.9
> >>>>
> >>>> I'm curious about the changes in RHEL 7 that make supporting 6.x a
> >>>> challenge -- can you share?
> >>>>
> >>>>> -----Original Message-----
> >>>>> From: frog [mailto:frog-bounces at lists.frrouting.org] On Behalf Of Martin
> >>>>> Winter
> >>>>> Sent: Monday, October 01, 2018 7:49 AM
> >>>>> To: Netravnen
> >>>>> Cc: FRRouting-Dev; FRR Operator Group
> >>>>> Subject: Re: [FROG] [dev] Any CentOS/RedHat 6 FRR users out there?
> >>>>>
> >>>>> On 1 Oct 2018, at 4:09, Netravnen wrote:
> >>>>>
> >>>>>> On Mon, 1 Oct 2018 at 00:50, Martin Winter
> >>>>>> <mwinter at opensourcerouting.org> wrote:
> >>>>>>> I’m trying to see how common the (old) CentOS 6 / RedHat 6 is as it
> >>>>>>> becomes increasingly difficult to support.
> >>>>>> Would it make sense to announce FRR 6.x as the last official release
> >>>>>> supported on CentOS / RedHat 6.x ?
> >>>>> We would if we decide to go this way.
> >>>>>
> >>>>> At this time, we are still trying to understand (and get feedback) on
> >>>> the
> >>>>> impact if we decide to go this way.
> >>>>>
> >>>>> Regards,
> >>>>>    Martin Winter
> >>>>>
> >>>>> _______________________________________________
> >>>>> frog mailing list
> >>>>> frog at lists.frrouting.org
> >>>>> https://lists.frrouting.org/listinfo/frog
> >>>>
> >>>>
> >>>> begin 666 smime.p7s
> >>>> M,( &"2J&2(;W#0$'`J" ,( "`0$Q"S )!@4K#@,"&@4`,( &"2J&2(;W#0$'
> >>>> M`0``H((.$3""!#8P@@,>H ,"`0("`0$P#08)*H9(AO<-`0$%!0`P;S$+, D&
> >>>> M`U4$!A,"4T4Q%# 2!@-5! H3"T%D9%1R=7-T($%",28P) 8#500+$QU!9&14
> >>>> M<G5S="!%>'1E<FYA;"!45% @3F5T=V]R:S$B," &`U4$`Q,9061D5')U<W0@
> >>>> M17AT97)N86P at 0T$@4F]O=# >%PTP,# U,S Q,#0X,SA:%PTR,# U,S Q,#0X
> >>>> M,SA:,&\Q"S )!@-5! 83`E-%,10P$@8#500*$PM!9&14<G5S="!!0C$F,"0&
> >>>> M`U4$"Q,=061D5')U<W0 at 17AT97)N86P at 5%10($YE='=O<FLQ(C @!@-5! ,3
> >>>> M&4%D9%1R=7-T($5X=&5R;F%L($-!(%)O;W0P@@$B, T&"2J&2(;W#0$!`04`
> >>>> M`X(!#P`P@@$*`H(!`0"W]QHSYO(`!"TYX$Y;[1^\; _-M?HCML[>FQ$SEZ0I
> >>>> M3'V3G[U*O)/M`QKCC\_E;5!:UI<IE%J L$EZVRZ5_;C*OS<X+1X^D4&M<%;'
> >>>> M\$\_Z#*>=,K(D%3IQE\/>)V:0#P.K&&J7A2/GH>A:E#<UYI.KP6SIG&4G'&S
> >>>> M4& *QQ.=. >&`JCIJ&DF&)"K3+!/(ZLZ3X38W\Z?X6EON]="UVM$Y,>M[FU!
> >>>> M7W):<0 at WLWEEI%F at E#?W`"\-PI)RVM X<ML4J$7$72I]M[36Q.ZLS1-$M\DK
> >>>> MW4,`)?IAN6EJ6",1MZ<SCU9U6?7-*==&MPHK9;;30F\5LKA[^^_I75/5-%HG
> >>>> M`@,!``&C@=PP@=DP'08#51T.!!8$%*V]F'HTM";W^L0F5.\#O> DRU0:, L&
> >>>> M`U4=#P0$`P(!!C /!@-5'1,!`?\$!3 #`0'_,(&9!@-5'2,$@9$P at 8Z %*V]
> >>>> MF'HTM";W^L0F5.\#O> DRU0:H7.D<3!O,0LP"08#500&$P)313$4,!(&`U4$
> >>>> M"A,+061D5')U<W0 at 04(Q)C D!@-5! L3'4%D9%1R=7-T($5X=&5R;F%L(%14
> >>>> M4"!.971W;W)K,2(P( 8#500#$QE!9&14<G5S="!%>'1E<FYA;"!#02!2;V]T
> >>>> M@@$!, T&"2J&2(;W#0$!!04``X(!`0"PF^"%)<+6(^(/E@:2G4&8G-F$>8'9
> >>>> M'EL4!R,V98^PV'>[K$%L1V"#4;#Y,CWG_/8F$\> %J6_6OR'SWAYB2&:XDP'
> >>>> M"H8UO/+>4<32EK?<?D[N</T<.>L,`E$4+8Z]%N#!WT9UYR2M[/1"M(63<!!G
> >>>> MNIT&-4H8TRMZS%%"H7ICT>:[H<4KPC:^$PWFO6-^>7NG"0U JVK=CXK#]O:,
> >>>> M&D(%4=1%]9^G8B%H%2!#/)GG?+TDV*F1%W.(/U8;,3 at 8M'$/FLW(#IZ.+AOA
> >>>> MC)B#RQ\Q\41,Q at 1S279@#\?XO1> :R[IS$P.6IIY#R *+M6>8R8>59*4V((7
> >>>> M6GO0O,>/3H8$,(($KS""`Y>@`P(!`@(1`. CRQ42 at U.)K6%N>E1G:R$P#08)
> >>>> M*H9(AO<-`0$+!0`P;S$+, D&`U4$!A,"4T4Q%# 2!@-5! H3"T%D9%1R=7-T
> >>>> M($%",28P) 8#500+$QU!9&14<G5S="!%>'1E<FYA;"!45% @3F5T=V]R:S$B
> >>>> M," &`U4$`Q,9061D5')U<W0 at 17AT97)N86P at 0T$@4F]O=# >%PTQ-#$R,C(P
> >>>> M,# P,#!:%PTR,# U,S Q,#0X,SA:,(&;,0LP"08#500&$P)'0C$;,!D&`U4$
> >>>> M"!,21W)E871E<B!-86YC:&5S=&5R,1 P#@8#500'$P=386QF;W)D,1HP& 8#
> >>>> M500*$Q%#3TU/1$\@0T$@3&EM:71E9#%!,#\&`U4$`Q,X0T]-3T1/(%-(02TR
> >>>> M-38 at 0VQI96YT($%U=&AE;G1I8V%T:6]N(&%N9"!396-U<F4 at 16UA:6P at 0T$P
> >>>> M@@$B, T&"2J&2(;W#0$!`04``X(!#P`P@@$*`H(!`0")L0W:>E,93G!2';Q6
> >>>> MI at 8FM[A)X);G4:OQ\%H3216CM(P;8+QZ44*G>8RD(M\784Z1U78C"A332@)_
> >>>> MMAT)@&ZE!#W9NKL6_J&'J2Y#4D,6?*\R4,BF3UKI"-C/DR6<>XCH,&3FI/A6
> >>>> M@/TJ)!0S%YFL1.5IBZ-&!DO",]3I0)\&L+&LDT"YM0B3.IPJ4Z,0VST at 83Q5
> >>>> M`X[93G8E`B$I^J-\<79/[N%?@>G[5(#;PWLU4K>$WB(]+# M,7]9O5(WL#-I
> >>>> M+4/K^M:E\9=W9U&,V>XGZ[RE!SAVC*2I./_?C/4#K$F^RO=SF3H/,JN<E3H3
> >>>> M/0Y&.E=T85"^QD _R^3BGZ(A`@,!``&C@@$7,((!$S ?!@-5'2,$&# 6@!2M
> >>>> MO9AZ-+0F]_K$)E3O`[W@),M4&C =!@-5'0X$%@04DF%K at N&BH*I/[&?QPJ/W
> >>>> MM( `P>PP#@8#51T/`0'_! 0#`@&&,!(&`U4=$P$!_P0(, 8!`?\"`0`P'08#
> >>>> M51TE!!8P% 8(*P8!!04'`P(&""L&`04%!P,$,!$&`U4=( 0*, @P!@8$51T@
> >>>> M`#!$!@-5'1\$/3 [,#F at -Z UAC-H='1P.B\O8W)L+G5S97)T<G5S="YC;VTO
> >>>> M061D5')U<W1%>'1E<FYA;$-!4F]O="YC<FPP-08(*P8!!04'`0$$*3 G,"4&
> >>>> M""L&`04%!S !AAEH='1P.B\O;V-S<"YU<V5R=')U<W0N8V]M, T&"2J&2(;W
> >>>> M#0$!"P4``X(!`0`;*FZL5<$ZJXC%V.W-5?.J:V$KP D0(YD/Q69J;['UM+5W
> >>>> M7@\"80#??07^$K.D@( `_/L=6VIR`@I!O 6ZP5C5)L+JU4V$^_Z"F,]8&^,B
> >>>> M8YQ2^+L%-JM]6*7>JSMCY=K5<^_LX/M[XJ/_\$(CG,JVC4T^Y$L8`[*H+=38
> >>>> MNT)+D&F%$-NF-S3H>^ !$*6<RCK'GT^(-&Z*9= :BKNIW,K*-M'T_,)D*36O
> >>>> MUK&G<1'2`T.QCSZ:[)XR4_1VDLJ&- >Y+,KF'$K8F0W!AN*0DOM:0FHC(1#I
> >>>> M9<?UU;M^ZHR%( )BZM$Z!RQ9Q9DS\CB)Y;;I%GH?>13V2A :)OI\BON;,((%
> >>>> M(#""! B@`P(!`@(1`(+-2':;XZ#&U!G>^P&7OJPP#08)*H9(AO<-`0$+!0`P
> >>>> M at 9LQ"S )!@-5! 83`D=",1LP&08#500($Q)'<F5A=&5R($UA;F-H97-T97(Q
> >>>> M$# .!@-5! <3!U-A;&9O<F0Q&C 8!@-5! H3$4-/34]$3R!#02!,:6UI=&5D
> >>>> M,4$P/P8#500#$SA#3TU/1$\@4TA!+3(U-B!#;&EE;G0 at 075T:&5N=&EC871I
> >>>> M;VX at 86YD(%-E8W5R92!%;6%I;"!#03 >%PTQ-S Q,3 at P,# P,#!:%PTR,# Q
> >>>> M,3 at R,S4Y-3E:," Q'C <!@DJADB&]PT!"0$6#VII;4!C87)R;VQL+F-O;3""
> >>>> M`2(P#08)*H9(AO<-`0$!!0`#@@$/`#""`0H"@@$!`+>;EY]ERMD$,P;8"I7X
> >>>> M?^ /F69VS8/L_HEV(J#N= $S];)Z)NSNCEKQQL*V\)X*[3:U#K&RT"]7`^(9
> >>>> M/]<<)D]QC$]^CQB)W6&GH=]!S)"#BX#@1Q)ZRNK%`>L!^4T4%*7SH4#L9W*4
> >>>> MT$5<*UR%\T_56N':G<DYHV-9.='BNEU"'%TY+[]LYZ=B>CA]ND5XQ(/B6G)$
> >>>> M+.45284OBU4BNP&F^_G1,%^"$.,_`")HQ!K_IW :.=0"J38^R&!!*H#$V>"H
> >>>> M\A*[L =HF*&;G2L'<8*^T%BY+7S.3D[>P=G4O*#;+C4>,]Q8'MX2A9 at G$#LC
> >>>> M'5]WL4$YZ?=VZ+H"B_33;&T"`P$``:."`=<P@@'3,!\&`U4=(P08,!: %))A
> >>>> M:X+AHJ"J3^QG\<*C][2 `,'L,!T&`U4=#@06!!2S>P/T;X" O18ML(68VK at Z
> >>>> M(7<123 .!@-5'0\!`?\$! ,"!: P# 8#51T3`0'_! (P`# =!@-5'24$%C 4
> >>>> M!@@K!@$%!0<#! 8(*P8!!04'`P(P1 at 8#51T@!#\P/3 [!@PK!@$$`;(Q`0(!
> >>>> M`P4P*S I!@@K!@$%!0<"`18=:'1T<',Z+R]S96-U<F4N8V]M;V1O+FYE="]#
> >>>> M4%,P708#51T?!%8P5#!2H%"@3H9,:'1T<#HO+V-R;"YC;VUO9&]C82YC;VTO
> >>>> M0T]-3T1/4TA!,C4V0VQI96YT075T:&5N=&EC871I;VYA;F1396-U<F5%;6%I
> >>>> M;$-!+F-R;#"!D 8(*P8!!04'`0$$@8,P at 8 P6 8(*P8!!04', *&3&AT=' Z
> >>>> M+R]C<G0N8V]M;V1O8V$N8V]M+T-/34]$3U-(03(U-D-L:65N=$%U=&AE;G1I
> >>>> M8V%T:6]N86YD4V5C=7)E16UA:6Q#02YC<G0P) 8(*P8!!04', &&&&AT=' Z
> >>>> M+R]O8W-P+F-O;6]D;V-A+F-O;3 :!@-5'1$$$S 1 at 0]J:6U 8V%R<F]L;"YC
> >>>> M;VTP#08)*H9(AO<-`0$+!0`#@@$!`'W33 4"-'Y3RQ+/>:PFSC at 28531Y 1V
> >>>> MH"=?*@"]NZ7+1X&;TMD)/=KS<3BZN1X<*%FAF5TT8@\9&Y)W7&M28.,GF/5,
> >>>> MV'!"E<-"(+ZQU&<SFY>52)<8(H0D6.RB<5"5L#EHH-[8IB]:W7W0)9<VHV>A
> >>>> M3OF,X]<-(XS5!1:<VY>/Q-+\ZA; \X:\/*#59:$JD)8S.TZ20:Q(!CUZ+E[A
> >>>> M!-V6+Y9+9_#2CX G4C7LD,*>D_T?J?X.7^&M(*ZE=+5X$_)7^:4-5GJCO[GY
> >>>> MC*7/4G($(0<G(B/8FO<=,%\M\-V**+[KKM<%HL at AR69,=HU Y_GU3PBE![J;
> >>>> MWYTVZ97^?=PQ@@0C,(($'P(!`3"!L3"!FS$+, D&`U4$!A,"1T(Q&S 9!@-5
> >>>> M! @3$D=R96%T97(@36%N8VAE<W1E<C$0, X&`U4$!Q,'4V%L9F]R9#$:,!@&
> >>>> M`U4$"A,10T]-3T1/($-!($QI;6ET960Q03 _!@-5! ,3.$-/34]$3R!32$$M
> >>>> M,C4V($-L:65N="!!=71H96YT:6-A=&EO;B!A;F0 at 4V5C=7)E($5M86EL($-!
> >>>> M`A$`@LU(=IOCH,;4&=[[`9>^K# )!@4K#@,"&@4`H(("1C 8!@DJADB&]PT!
> >>>> M"0,Q"P8)*H9(AO<-`0<!,!P&"2J&2(;W#0$)!3$/%PTQ.#$P,#$Q,34V-3-:
> >>>> M,",&"2J&2(;W#0$)!#$6!!2MK0$7EB:J_)US\-6X^!2-^[\J=S!;!@DJADB&
> >>>> M]PT!"0\Q3C!,, H&""J&2(;W#0,', X&""J&2(;W#0,"`@(`@# -!@@JADB&
> >>>> M]PT#`@(!0# '!@4K#@,"!S -!@@JADB&]PT#`@(!*# '!@4K#@,"&C"!P at 8)
> >>>> M*P8!! &"-Q $,8&T,(&Q,(&;,0LP"08#500&$P)'0C$;,!D&`U4$"!,21W)E
> >>>> M871E<B!-86YC:&5S=&5R,1 P#@8#500'$P=386QF;W)D,1HP& 8#500*$Q%#
> >>>> M3TU/1$\@0T$@3&EM:71E9#%!,#\&`U4$`Q,X0T]-3T1/(%-(02TR-38 at 0VQI
> >>>> M96YT($%U=&AE;G1I8V%T:6]N(&%N9"!396-U<F4 at 16UA:6P at 0T$"$0""S4AV
> >>>> MF^. at QM09WOL!E[ZL,('$!@LJADB&]PT!"1 ""S&!M*"!L3"!FS$+, D&`U4$
> >>>> M!A,"1T(Q&S 9!@-5! @3$D=R96%T97(@36%N8VAE<W1E<C$0, X&`U4$!Q,'
> >>>> M4V%L9F]R9#$:,!@&`U4$"A,10T]-3T1/($-!($QI;6ET960Q03 _!@-5! ,3
> >>>> M.$-/34]$3R!32$$M,C4V($-L:65N="!!=71H96YT:6-A=&EO;B!A;F0 at 4V5C
> >>>> M=7)E($5M86EL($-!`A$`@LU(=IOCH,;4&=[[`9>^K# -!@DJADB&]PT!`0$%
> >>>> M``2"`0!2;U0"W\1A;-LG;##2XGNJA0Y_8U,R6V7;)@>3<I^"/4^,.OA+HP[/
> >>>> M79\K8<?0YX"E=R:%DY9(XM+,_R^O)/O1EC\==W9GYZ'<Y99GAP+%O1HJI\ T
> >>>> MS[31B_F).J?>-_ECJ\L;Q].(G at _['[0141'5D!;Q]=LH at 164<H0ONV6'62NI
> >>>> M^[>R8^ ^X_TPL\IF.+_4B"X2-INJDV!^?(V,EI".4(Z G_<^CS 9KG_&MMYD
> >>>> M[J!U$\QCQE@^_58PB-HA[;H^83 at 7*JPOFS[0[4![9]\'- KP`N%^&GP1F+XU
> >>>> JWEO-;MM7OA?C9X8NM-B2L3W-&\-?V#MC.$>QU[L8[*7[$>^T````````
> >>>> `
> >>>> end
> >>>>
> >>>>
> >>>> _______________________________________________
> >>>> frog mailing list
> >>>> frog at lists.frrouting.org
> >>>> https://lists.frrouting.org/listinfo/frog
> >>> _______________________________________________
> >>> frog mailing list
> >>> frog at lists.frrouting.org
> >>> https://lists.frrouting.org/listinfo/frog
> >>
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> dev mailing list
> dev at lists.frrouting.org
> https://lists.frrouting.org/listinfo/dev



-- 
Renato Westphal



More information about the frog mailing list